Hyperparathyroidism Blog 

from the Experts at the Norman Parathyroid Center

Interesting stories of hyperparathyroidism we see every day.  Parathyroid blog published bi-weekly.

FNA (Fine Needle Aspiration) Biopsy of Parathyroid Adenoma

FNA (Fine Needle Aspiration) Biopsy of Parathyroid Adenoma

Biopsy of parathyroid adenomas can be dangerous and is almost always unnecessary. Parathyroid glands should almost never be biopsied (FNA biopsy).

Fine-needle aspiration (FNA) biopsy of parathyroid adenomas is a procedure we would love to see disappear! One of the parathyroid operations that I performed this week that really stood out from the others was in a wonderful, somewhat chatty lady from New Jersey. Her PCP noted that she had high calcium and correctly proposed that the high calcium was why “Little Miss Chatty” was feeling so tired all of the time. She was sent to an endocrinologist who ordered “about 20 test tubes of blood” and a couple of scans so they “could find the tumor for the surgeon.” The diagnosis of primary hyperparathyroidism was easy to make actually: her blood calcium level of 10.8 was obviously high and her parathyroid hormone (PTH) level of 116 was far outside the normal range.  Well, the sestamibi scan showed the parathyroid tumor, but her endocrinologist wanted to give her local surgeon a helping hand by performing a needle biopsy (called a Fine Needle Aspiration Biopsy, or FNA) to PROVE it was a parathyroid so that the surgeon would know where to look for it in surgery. So an ultrasound was done, and  the parathyroid tumor was punctured with a needle, sucking out some fluid and cells to send to the lab to confirm what is, frankly, already known: there is a parathyroid adenoma in “Little Miss Chatty’s” neck!

Parathyroid surgery was a simple solution… right up until the needle-stick. Fine-needle aspiration (FNA) biopsy of a parathyroid tumor causes fluid to seep out of the tumor and stick to everything around it. Now this makes parathyroidectomy (a routine, outpatient, safe, simple operation) into a technically difficult, risky challenge, to say the least. When this doctor was trying to “help” the surgeon, she actually made the operation 10 times harder, twice as long, and increased the risk for injury to the nerve to her voice box during the operation. Our group published an important paper on needle biopsy of parathyroid glands several years ago (see footnote below). In this paper we described how much more difficult parathyroid operations are when the parathyroid tumor has been stuck with a needle!

Fine-needle aspiration (FNA) biopsy of parathyroid adenomas causes intense scar tissue that makes the adenoma stick to the surrounding anatomy. Is that so bad? Well, yes. When the surrounding anatomy is the nerve to the voice box (ie., the recurrent laryngeal nerve), it can be very dicey. The recurrent laryngeal nerve doesn’t particularly like for you to blow it a kiss, much less peel a scarred tumor off it! Naturally, FNA thus adds time to an otherwise quick procedure, because we have to tiptoe around this nerve when it would usually be brushed away from possible harm with a single swipe of a cottonball.

Another problem with sticking a parathyroid tumor with a needle (FNA Biopsy) is that the scar reaction from the needlestick also makes our pathologist think they are looking at parathyroid cancer under the microscope. Who could blame them? Parathyroid cancer (the rarest of rare cancers) looks just like this–scarred and stuck to things around it! Starting to sound like that simple FNA biopsy of the parathyroid adenoma wasn’t so helpful after all? We have learned to avoid patients who have had their parathyroid biopsied with a needle, and have on occasion refused to take patients into our practice that have had this done. The problems this can cause in some patients cannot be overstated.
In this case, I removed her tumor in 26 minutes (a little longer than our average time of under 20 minutes), but it was time well-spent: Little Miss has a normal voice and remains chatty!
Biopsy and Fine Needle Biopsy of Parathyroid Adenomas.

Parathyroid biopsy article published in 2007 by Dr Politz and partners.

Watch the video!
Calcium-Pro is an accurate and easy-to-use parathyroid app for patients and doctors made by parathyroid doctors—from Calcium Science.

Click here to download Calcium-Pro in the Apple App Store

Click here to download Calcium-Pro on Google Play

About Dr. Douglas Politz

Dr. Douglas Politz

Dr. Doug Politz is one of the world's most knowledgeable parathyroid doctors and the second most experienced parathyroid surgeon in the world. Dr. Politz attended LSU Medical School where he graduated with the Chancellor’s Award as the Most Outstanding Graduate. Dr. Politz obtained his surgical training at the University of South Florida in Tampa, working with Dr. Norman for 5 years. Doug is a member of over a dozen surgical societies and is a fellow of the American College of Surgeons (FACS) and the American College of Endocrinology (FACE). He has been awarded the "Patients Choice Award" 8 consecutive years (top 3% of all American doctors), has been named one of America's Top Surgeons annually for over a decade. Dr. Politz has been a senior surgeon at the Norman Parathyroid Center since 2005 and has dedicated his surgical career to the treatment of hyperparathyroidism.

Get the Calcium-Pro parathyroid diagnosis app for smart phones and tablets developed by our experts.

Norman Parathyroid Center · (813) 972-0000 · Disclaimer